Oct. 28, 2008 Webinar: Journalism, Audience and Advertising on the Web

Press freedom in China

Member alert: Free Speech Protection Act

Celebrate National Freedom of Speech Week, Oct. 20-26

· A list of all reports   · ASNE Convention material
· Codes of Ethics   · Fundamental Documents
· News releases   · The American Editor
Page Location: Home » Archives » The American Editor » 1999 » October-November
A big arrest, an ill police chief and ‘W’

Author: Kathy L. Vetter
Published: November 11, 1999
Last Updated: January 26, 2000
Printer-friendly version

The front page

The Front Page is an occasional look at how our front pages reflect what our newspapers value. If you would like to have your front page considered, contact Al Siegal of The New York Times at 212/556-1049 or siegal@nytimes.com

News broke out on the local, state and international fronts on this day, forcing us to make some difficult decisions. The page reflects our understanding of what is important to our community and what touches the basic emotions of our readers.

Our first problem was how to give two stories — the arrest in the disappearance of a local 6-year-old and the police chief’s cancer diagnosis — sufficient play above the fold. Home delivery makes up a majority of our circulation, but rack sales are important in such a competitive market. We pay a great deal of attention to the top half of the page.

Opal Jennings was the second child to disappear from our area in two years, raising the emotional stakes for the community. We decided to blow out the arrest story. We chose the sidebar because it was a colorful read that offered insight into the main players and because it was something our competitors did not have.

We knew that the police chief’s illness would stun the community. He has overseen a big drop in the city’s crime rate and repaired the department’s relations with minorities, making him an integral part of the city’s sense of well-being. Stories that touch on people’s feelings of safety are an easy call: We knew this one would.

The second problem was how to tell our readers about the new education commissioner. We used the teasers. On a slower day, this would have been a Page One story. The Board of Education recommends textbooks, a controversial topic in our conservative, Bible Belt area.

Gov. George W. Bush’s campaign has been a Page One story since January. His answer to the drug question is relevant — and a cover story — because he is a law-and-order candidate from a law-and-order state (again, the Bible Belt).

Local news is our reason for being. Nevertheless, our market is large and diverse, and readers expect all the news of the day. Understanding that, we saved a spot for the horrible destruction in Turkey. It ran at the bottom of the page for two reasons: It was three days old, and it wasn’t unique. It had been all over the media for days.

By the way, the “To our readers” box is not a typical feature, but we needed to explain that a fire scare in the pressroom had delayed the previous morning’s delivery.

Vetter is managing editor/news for the Fort Worth (Texas) Star-Telegram.
 

© Copyright 2008 The American Society of Newspaper Editors
11690B Sunrise Valley Drive | Reston, VA 20191-1409 | Phone 703-453-1122