Shield law update: 41 attorneys general sign letter to be sent July 8

Follow-up to “Shield law help needed”

Shield Law help needed

An opportunity to help Iowa colleagues

· A list of all reports   · ASNE Convention material
· Codes of Ethics   · Fundamental Documents
· News releases   · The American Editor
Page Location: Home » Archives » The American Editor » 1996 » October
Letter to The Editor

Published: March 01, 1996
Last Updated: March 01, 1997
Printer-friendly version

Even with better media-military relations, reporters should always check it out

Frank A. Aukofer is to be commended for his efforts promoting more and better coverage and education in military matters to every journalism practitioner (The American Editor, September 1996).

In the rush to improve relations, however, we must never forget that the primary responsibility of journalists is less to cooperate with the military and more to view all of our sources with an arm's length healthy skepticism.

Although my experience helping cover the military in Hawaii during the Vietnam War showed me that most military and public relations sources are honorable men and women, the fact is that both institutions carry out different albeit essential roles not served by coupling, coziness and a Beltway-type in-house worldview that afflicts some of the best and brightest of our Washington and Pentagon correspondents.

A history of ASNE reveals similar problems when the watchdog press becomes less an adversary and more a cheerleader to keep the faith of the military-industrial complex. More recently, we see evidence of the military we are being asked to trust and odd couple with it as it ignores or conceals evidence concerning nerve gas exposure to 20,000 troops during the Gulf War.

In addition to the recommendations to improve coverage of the military with better trained reporters, journalists need to beware of being charmed and lured into the military comfort zone. When your mother (even if she wears Army boots) says she loves you, you better check it out.

Alf Pratte

Provo, Utah

© Copyright 2008 The American Society of Newspaper Editors
11690B Sunrise Valley Drive | Reston, VA 20191-1409 | Phone 703-453-1122